Post by Deleted on Apr 17, 2010 20:00:25 GMT 1
I recall a post on Rattle starting Rite of Spring over after a cell phone rang at the beginning. But he didn't start Brahms 2 over after 2 horn mistakes in the beginning.
A Amazon.com customer re Dvorak Serenade:
This recording fully meets my expectations in terms of excellent technical quality (us usually provided by Deutsche Grammophon) as well as interpretation by Berliner Philharmoniker & Karajan delivering "golden" sound. Nevertheless I should point out that this CD turned out to be the first ever for me to hear a serious playing slip by the musicians. The strings are certainly playing wrongly for a few seconds in track no. 6 (Allegro con moto - Trio) around the count of 4'00"" which caused quite some disappointment to me. I raised this point on the DG homepage and got the following answer on 29-June-2000:
Quote
"A playing slip?": You are right here. However, it is most likely that Karajan decided to allow the slip to stand because he believed an additional corrective take would not match the overall quality of the performance delivered albeit with that slip.
Unquote
A Amazon.com customer re Dvorak Serenade:
This recording fully meets my expectations in terms of excellent technical quality (us usually provided by Deutsche Grammophon) as well as interpretation by Berliner Philharmoniker & Karajan delivering "golden" sound. Nevertheless I should point out that this CD turned out to be the first ever for me to hear a serious playing slip by the musicians. The strings are certainly playing wrongly for a few seconds in track no. 6 (Allegro con moto - Trio) around the count of 4'00"" which caused quite some disappointment to me. I raised this point on the DG homepage and got the following answer on 29-June-2000:
Quote
"A playing slip?": You are right here. However, it is most likely that Karajan decided to allow the slip to stand because he believed an additional corrective take would not match the overall quality of the performance delivered albeit with that slip.
Unquote